Skip to content

9/11 treatment program may have to turn away first responders and survivors if lawmakers don’t expand capacity

  • Kelsey Alvarez, daughter of Det. Luis Alvarez, speaks during his...

    Richard Drew/AP

    Kelsey Alvarez, daughter of Det. Luis Alvarez, speaks during his funeral mass at Immaculate Conception Church in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019. Alvarez, 53, died on June 29 after a three-year battle with colorectal cancer.

  • An NYPD musician attends the funeral of 9/11 first responder...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    An NYPD musician attends the funeral of 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019.

  • Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez greets a mourner at the funeral for...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez greets a mourner at the funeral for 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019.

  • Lainie, the wife of 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez,...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Lainie, the wife of 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez, holds the American flag folded for her alongside his son David (l.) at his funeral in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019.

  • Former talkshow host and advocate John Stewart at the funeral...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Former talkshow host and advocate John Stewart at the funeral of 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez in Queens, New York on July 3, 2019.

  • Lainie, the wife of 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez,...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Lainie, the wife of 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez, and his son David (l.) stand together at his funeral in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019.

  • Former talk show host John Stewart (l.), who appeared with...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Former talk show host John Stewart (l.), who appeared with Alvarez during his June meeting with Congress, and Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney, speak at the funeral of 9/11 first responder's funeral on July 3, 2019.

  • Police officers, family members and mourners gather outside of the...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Police officers, family members and mourners gather outside of the Immaculate Conception Church in Astoria, Queens for the funeral of 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez on July 3, 2019. The revered detective lost his battle with a 9/11-related cancer on June 29.

  • Det. Luis Alvarez's casket is carried out of Immaculate Conception...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Det. Luis Alvarez's casket is carried out of Immaculate Conception Church in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019 following his funeral.

  • Family members of 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez exit...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Family members of 9/11 first responder Det. Luis Alvarez exit the Immaculate Conception Church in Astoria, Queens following his funeral on July 3, 2019.

  • Police Commissioner James O'Neill attends the funeral of 9/11 first...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Police Commissioner James O'Neill attends the funeral of 9/11 first responder Luis Alvarez in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019.

  • Det. Luis Alvarez's casket is carried out of Immaculate Conception...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Det. Luis Alvarez's casket is carried out of Immaculate Conception Church in Astoria, Queens following his funeral service in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019. Less than one month ago on June 11, Alvarez sat before members of Congress to call for compensation to be given to those like him who risked their lives surveying Ground Zero following 9/11 in the early 2000s.

  • Mourners cry during Det. Luis Alvarez's funeral at the Immaculate...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Mourners cry during Det. Luis Alvarez's funeral at the Immaculate Conception Church in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019.

  • In this Sept 13, 2001 file photo, firefighters use cellphones...

    BETH A. KEISER/AP

    In this Sept 13, 2001 file photo, firefighters use cellphones as they take a break outside the Ladder 10 Engine 10 firehouse across the street from the World Trade Center site in New York.

  • Police officers fold the American flag for Alvarez's widow Lanie...

    Danielle Hyams/NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

    Police officers fold the American flag for Alvarez's widow Lanie during his funeral service on July 3, 2019.

  • Rev. John P. Harrington blesses the casket during the funeral...

    Richard Drew/AP

    Rev. John P. Harrington blesses the casket during the funeral ceremony for Det. Luis Alvarez, at Immaculate Conception Church in Astoria, Queens on July 3, 2019.

of

Expand
Author
PUBLISHED: | UPDATED:

Sept. 11 responders who are not yet in the 9/11 treatment program could be facing a new roadblock, according to a letter from the federal government that warns lawmakers the number of slots available for ill people is nearing its maximum.

The letter, sent Wednesday by Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, was required by the 2015 law that made the World Trade Center Health Program permanent.

Under the law, enrollment was capped at 25,000 responders and 25,000 survivors. The secretary was required to warn lawmakers when signups hit 20,000 in either category.

According to the message from Azar, that number is being reached early this month for responders.

While it doesn’t affect anyone getting treatment now, Azar said that sometime after late 2020, the enrollment cap would be hit, and no new people would be allowed in.

“Based on current projections, the WTC health Program anticipates that the number of newly enrolled responders will reach 80 percent of the statutory enrollment numerical limitation in early September of 2019, and the full numerical limitation will be met 25,000 numerical limitation will be met sometime between October 2020 and February 2021,” Azar’s letter says.

He adds that the 20,000-enrollment warning trigger for survivors will not be hit for several years.

It will be up to Congress to fix the situation by either raising the caps or eliminating them.

A joint statement from a half dozen members of Congress involved in the legislation called the problem a “technical issue that can be easily fixed” and won’t hurt anyone already in the program before the caps are hit.

“We are working now to make sure no future applicants are impacted,” the statement said, though it did not offer a specific cure.

It added that Congress included the trigger in the original 9/11 bill to make sure lawmakers would have time to respond if enrollments surged, as they have.

“We built in this noticing requirement for when the program reached 80% of the new enrollee caps so that Congress would have more than enough time to act,” said the statement. “This is the program working as intended.”

A fix to remove or increase the caps seems likely to pass Congress easily after the recent high-profile push to permanently extend the separate 9/11 Victim Compensation Fund, which brought dying responders and comedian Jon Stewart to Capitol Hill.

That struggle wound up with legislators uniting more on any big-ticket spending proposal than they have in years, passing permanent compensation with just a handful of opponents.

Upgrading the limits on the treatment program should be easier since it would carry no direct budgetary impact. Funding for the effort has already been specified in law through 2025, and will rise with inflation after that.

Funding could eventually become an issue if rising enrollments collide with increasing medical costs somewhere down the road, but medical costs are hard to guess five and 10 years in the future, especially for numbers of responders and survivors that are changing.

News of the treatment limits came as another reminder of 9/11 surfaced Thursday. The Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee announced it would hold a field hearing on Monday at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum on current national security challenges.

Three past Homeland Security secretaries from the Bush and Obama administrations are expected to testify.